VHS ERA trick was dope and I for one like to see the occasional struggle on a trick even if that means arms flailing, sometimes that actually looks sick especially on really hard tricks. that being said this one definitely looks like you could easily re-do one you'd be entirely satisfied with (doesn't have to be picture perfect either - it's a thin line, but the difference really is what matters, you'll know it when you feel it). actually that's probably where your hesitation comes from, rather than other people's impressions - those only resonate with you because they highlight a certain way you already feel about your clip, having to do with insecurities keeping this clip all the while knowing you're really capable of more, or better. I'd say maybe go back and try to get a better one just in case, and if for some reason that doesn't happen well fuck it, you've done it anyway, it's happened and that's how it happened to look like. something funny to think about is how that same trick probably would have looked good anyway had it been filmed VX (or just fisheye), because it would have been dynamic. static HD angles just have the viewer expect picture perfect smoothness for some reason, sketch (good or bad) don't really work well with those, the same way having elliott smith stuck in my head for hours due to my girl's morning playlist fucked with my 360 flips on the skatepark hip the whole day yesterday...
everybody's been killing it. special mention to DaSk8D00D's rock kickflip, that was fucking wild. johnes, that's a good concept for a trick, as a kid i remember fantasizing over the idea of doing exactly what you did, just while moving and riding along the edge of the curb, and actually i have a friend in paris who does a trick that's very similar to yours ! toward the end of this, in the line with the crooked grind (not me !) :
and here's for my contribution, all wonky manuals. first spot in the first clip was tons of fun. second clip is just something random i happened to improvise on the go while that kid was filming everybody, and he caught it.