melee combat and fps don't mix well. neither do zombie games and fps either
I don't know if you guys ever played this game:
It was FPS, George A. Romero slow zombies, and tons of Melee and it was fucking awesome albeit linear.
If they could pull this off in Dead Island but have an open area (GTA/Oblivion style gameplay) I could see this game being really good.
But yea I'm with max, gameplay footage or screens or GTFO, I hate when developers hype theri games with trailers that have no correlation to gameplay.