Since I've met a lot of guys, I'm limiting this to OKCupid - I've met plenty others through gay.com, Bear411, and wrestling personals sites. It's super easy to meet gay dudes. I saw this after I broke up with my ex and decided to sign up for it… because of this thread.
It's been pretty good, so I'll break it down to the people I've met:
1. We both met for wrestling, which was something I wanted to do for 20+ years. 39 y.o., 205lb and very sexy. He wore boxer-briefs with a pouch and I wore my trusty Speedos. It was fucking awesome and sexy, and ended up in bed, but since I can't really get off with anyone, I ended up jacking off to the thought of us wrestling earlier. He's rather sex-driven, and I'm not into that. If I don't like a guy if he was straight, I have no interest.
2. Just a really cute undergrad, doesn't speak very good English, but we've talked a couple times. I want to cuddle with him, but it's possible he could be my student later this year.
3. A really cute, bigger guy, but is pretty dumb. He started talking to me because he saw my profile and wants to wrestle. He says he even has blue-and-white trunks, and that makes me very, very excited. We have only met for tea so far, and although we get along, we're on different levels.
4. A guy in his late 30s that I saw in town, after seeing his profile. He had surgery, so we can't wrestle yet, but hopefully someday. Cuddles and kisses, he even gave me a key to his house within 3 months of knowing each other so I could walk his dog when he needs to go.
5. A guy who looked like a solid human being, but is actually shitty. The first clue was his spiked hair, and he was balding. When we started checking out a museum together, it was fine. However, when we went to eat Chinese food, he got pissed at the new cashier because she couldn't get his order right; she didn't speak English well. It was embarrassing. Garbage.
6. A straight bearish guy. Also a music nerd, runs a local music blog, books shows, is starting to put out tapes. Polyamorous. Dry wit. He's just really fucking awesome, and would definitely cuddle with him if he was up for it.
I haven't met yet:
7. A 22-year-old cub who is in love with me. He has low self-esteem, and so because of the fact that I said he's cute, he thinks I'm The One. It's totally unrequited, because I had no further intentions than just that one message. I think he's a sweet kid, but he doesn't understand love. He lives a couple hours away and we both don't have a car, so he wants to Skype a lot. I have done cyber sex with him twice. I agreed that we will JO together someday, but that's it. When we do meet each other, I'm going to have to break his heart and tell him the truth about love, how we aren't going to be together, and how he just needs to be patient. It's going to fucking suck, but it's necessary.