Got mine today. As someone with a small and narrow foot, I can see how people with a wide foot would have a problem with this shoe. It's tight even on me. I suspect once the leather breaks in the Dylans will be more comfortable. The shoe really only works on me if I'm dressing up nice (think business casual or going out on the town) or trying out for Team Handsome. I'm having second thoughts to be honest. $120 is a lot of money....