for go my initial opinion, I do realize that they've kept their image a bit too long and yes early Josh Harmony era was terrible.
As someone else said good and evil and other videos after had solid Butcher, Marks, JLay, Trapasso, there was rad skating yes Dashawn Jordan killed it recent iterations as well as their heyday.
if we were to look at them as whole what's your favorite era of Toy Machine? easily Jump off a Building Maldonado, Steamer, Margera, BA, now with Foundation they've had such an revolving team it's hard to keep up and remember I only mentioned CA and That's Life as I was really paying attention to them at the time and living in Colorado where it was being filmed somewhat.