about 8 or 10 years ago a Deluxe/high speed employee told me SOTY is not chose by Phelps (as people loved to get mad at Jake) or by the voting. I think years back it was that way, but now it is a complete different method.
-Now each shoe company approaches Thrasher with a year long marketing scheme they will do through out the upcoming year with Thrasher and the skater they put forward who is going to film parts, interviews, covers etc. to be worthy of SOTY. A couple cpmpanies do this, Thrasher decides who they will go with and SOTY is eventually announced. I'm not saying this is true, but I was told so and and it seems to make sense. Look at some of the stuff that dropped right before SOTY, seems like they knew.
If it was THRASHER skater of the year it would seem like T-Funk who filmed a full-blown SF ripping part would have won?
T-Funk has no shoe deal so he had no chance, if the above info was true.