I watched Mindfield today and was definitely in agreement that it was the superior full package... but then I watched Stay Gold again and it wasn't as clear cut as I thought. After Mindfield, I appreciated the lack of drawn out interludes and nonsense in Stay Gold. The beginning back to back of Westgate and Herman parts quite honestly beats anything in Mindfield - and I'm saying that as a diehard Kalis fan. Each video has a few guys that taint it a bit like Berra or Braydon - nobody's perfect. Reynolds got the better ender, but part of that for me is because he doesn't skate to Morrisey. Minus a few points to Heath for the music choice. Also minus points to Mindfield for the intro using fucking bagpipes and going on for way too long. Technical foul for overuse of Dino Jr, though the ref agrees that Dino Jr is rad.
Final verdict - Stay Gold by a hair for me, but I'm partial to California skateboarding and I get sick of long chunks of bullshit interlude stuff in videos after the first viewing. Both videos are awesome, I can understand liking either better.