Last pair of old skools I've had were the Pro ones a while back, but I did have the Skate Lampin, Rowans and Half Cabs and they were all really good. The sole held better on the "skate" ones, the pros got soggy pretty quick. Had a pair of Dicksons when they came out and they were also really good, probably better than the pros and on par with the skate vans. I'd say you can't really go wrong with either so just pick the ones you like best.