My favorite skate shoes are ones I remember skating in high school before I had knee surgery, which changed skating in a few different ways for me.
Remember skating a couple pairs of Accels because I loved that shoe, and dug the Es Koston 1 a lot. There was a Circa shoe Appleyard skated all the time before his pro shoe, that was a lot of fun to skate. I also remember liking the Appleyard Circa shoe as well.
Overall, the Accels were probably my favorite from back in the day.
Currently the CTAS pro is probably my favorite to skate in. About to start skating some one stars soon, but they are nearly past being broken in from using them at work.