Expand Quote
Expand Quote
Expand Quote
Expand Quote
Expand Quote
This works for the fakie crook, but there’s still one point of contradiction when using this logic for the fakie Ollie to (regular) back tail. The backside in backside tailslide refers only to the orientation to the ledge before locking in, it has no bearing on the direction of the slide or what the slide looks like. So if you fakie Ollie with your front facing the ledge, and the ledge isn’t behind you before you lock in, it’s a contradiction to say that it’s a backside trick at any point.
It’s fine that this is the generally accepted name, but there’s no denying there’s some logical inconsistency to it. If the ledge isn’t behind you before you get in, it by definition cannot be a backside trick. It makes much more sense to call it a fakie front tail as it’s literally a frontside tailslide done in reverse, just like a fakie front 5-0 is a front 5-0 done in reverse.
I have to disagree here. The opposite of frontside is backside, not fakie. Fakie is the opposite of forwards, which is sideways body-wise. The reason a fakie 5-0 is fakie is because you are going fakie. The reason a fakie tail slide is fakie can only be because of the stance you enter it in because you are moving laterally with respect to the board, not forwards or backwards. I hope that makes sense.
To me a tailslide is backside because you are not facing the direction of travel, frontside because you are. In the original form of the trick it was probably called frontsdie and backside tailslide because of how you turned to get into it. Its confusing here though because none of that applies to boardslides, perhaps because they are a very primitive trick maybe developed first on transition.
I neither said nor implied that the opposite of frontside is fakie. There's no denying that a the fakie tail we're debating is geometrically the same as a front tail, except all motions in reverse which is why it would be very simple and coherent to call it a fakie front tail. This would also make the naming consistent with fakie front nosegrind and fakie front 5-0.
I understand your point about moving laterally with respect to the board, that is fine. However when you say that to you a tailslide is backside because you're not facing the direction of travel, you're completely throwing away the universally accepted definition of backside/frontside for ledge tricks, which is body orientation. By doing this, you're opening up a whole new can of worms. Why should your rule only apply to tailslides/lipslides/noseblunts? If we go by your definition for slide tricks (lateral motions), we'd have to call backside noseslides frontside, and frontside bluntslides backside etc. Having to make arbitrary exceptions is inefficient and leads to confusion.
All this really could be so simple. When new skaters are confused as to why a frontside boardslide isn't called backside, we tell them that the way you face when you slide is irrelevant, and it's your orientation relative to the obstacle before getting in that matters.
Why should this be different for fakie? You roll up to the ledge fakie, it's in front of you, you pop off your tail and slide on your tail. Fakie frontside tailslide, so straightforward. No rules broken, no contradictions.
Just name the basic part of the trick as it would be called if you just ollied into it. Then put the rest in front. Works fine.
For example riding fakie with the ledge behind you. Cab to nose slide is fs nose despite the starting position or that imaginary rewind thing that somehow has creeped into trick naming.
Riding regular with the ledge in front of you. Fs Ollie into switch 5050->it’s bs for same reasons.
The problem with this is, the basic part of some tricks can't be regular ollie into. Consider a fakie frontside 5-0, there's no way you can do a regular ollie into a fakie 5-0. Which is why people either a) name the basic part of the trick as it would be if you switched ollied into it, (fakie ollie to switch nosegrind) or b) just name the trick the what it would be if the complete motion of the trick was reversed and you were rolling forwards. (fakie 5-0)
Now if we "just name the basic part of the trick as it would be called if you just ollied into it", we're going to need two sets of rules: One set of rules for tricks that can't be regular ollied into eg fakie 5-0 (for some these we're going to have to pretend we switch ollie into resulting in even more confusion, or just label them as what the trick would be if the rolling direction were regular). One set of rules for tricks where you can "regular ollie into", but this sometimes involving breaking the frontside/backside rule: "A grind/slide is fs or bs depends on your orientation to the obstacle before getting into the trick."
The two examples you gave aren't very compelling because they both involve a turn of 180 degrees or more which physically changes or orientation relative to the ledge before you lock in, whereas a fakie tail involves a 90 degree turn at most and doesn't change your orientation relative to the ledge before you start sliding. I'll copy and paste what I said in the previous page with regards to someone giving a similar example:
"Consider a backside half cab backside 5050, I'm sure you know what trick I'm referring to, no confusion. Sure, you roll up to the ledge with your front facing it. However, notice I say "orientation to the obstacle before GETTING INTO the trick". You do a half cab, and before you lock into the grind, the ledge is behind you. It doesn't matter that the ledge is in front when you roll up, the trick into the grind (which changes your orientation) hasn't even occured yet. Hence half cab to backside 5050."
Well easiest way to get into the trick then. Before you lock into a back tail (no matter what trick you did to get into it) the ledge (the part of the ledge you are gonna slide on) is definitely behind you.
Not exactly. When I say orientation relative to the ledge before getting into a trick, I'm obviously referring to the most recent PARALLEL orientation before getting in, either your front or back. If you're referring to the millisecond before your tail hits the ledge, then strictly speaking for all slide tricks, the ledge is on the side of you, neither in front or behind. For example, a regular person doing a front tail, before you lock in, the ledge is on the right side of you when you lock in, not in front of you because your body is perpendicular to the ledge. The ledge orientation before locking in is referring to the most recent parallel orientation, otherwise you're going to open another giant can of worms and your nomenclature is going to get even messier. Also, 'easiest' way to get into something can be very subjective.