I don't really care who is the better skater, because that's irrelevant to the question, but come'on - Dixon's impact and legacy do not compare remotely to Duffel's. Duffel was a gigantic figure in skating at one of the peaks of the sport's popularity, and there were a number of years where every kid in skating dressed and attempted to skate like him. Duffel is just more popular that Dixon ever was or will be, no matter what you think about whether or not he deserves to be.