Surprised this thread isn’t bigger than it is.
For me, a beanie can’t be too bulky, and can’t be too tight either. I prefer acrylic over wool, since wool is too bulky imo. Can’t be too big or stick out too much, or be too small. The top has to be even and pointy if that makes sense.
The best beanie I have is an older Waters and Army. A now-defunct brand that was east coast based and used to sponsor Antonio Durao. Had it for years and it never lost its elasticity, and fits just as perfectly as it always did. If anyone has more, I’ll buy them.
In my experience, Dime and Grand also make good beanies. But even they don’t match the fit of the Waters and Army one. I have a Timberland beanie that isn’t half bad either. Quartersnacks makes good beanies as well.