For me, it was between Mikey Alfred, Mikey Taylor, Oblow and Transphobic Silverman.
I went with the latter two because they seemed ignorant to the point of hate/actually hurting ppl. What Oblow said was out of this world abhorrent and Transphobic Silverman kooked it mega-hard to play the victim and bring outsiders (Piers Morgan, Fox News, etc.) into our culture for her personal gain. Plus a 13 year old's almost opposite reaction to a similar circumstance just a month or so later made her look so much more kooky.
Mikey Alfred probably kooked it the hardest -- and is the biggest all-around perma kook -- but he's such an insignificant non-factor that it made him less deserving of the title, in my eyes. If we just continue to ignore him long enough, he will go away.
I almost gave it to Mikey Taylor, because he has succeeded in attaining public office, so his ignorant, "get-money"/Elon Musk Stan schtick can have real-world ramifications and be so much more dangerous. I'd like to think that if we ignore him, he will go away as well...but that seems less likely since he was elected to city council of a legitimate city. Still, I felt he did not win the award over Oblow or Silverman; he's just kind of silly. For now.
The alleged rapists like Tyler Warren are in a whole other category beyond KOTY so I didn't consider them.
Good poll!