Just in general, I'd really recommend the Japan Pro and Vickka Pro. The other shoes didn't really cut it for me.
Japan Pro is wide foot friendly and easily one of the most comfortable skate shoes in the past two years for me. They also skated very good, had great flick until probably the last few session, and lasted at least a month of skating (I flip my board a lot). Impact protection was actually pretty sufficient which is surprising since there really isn't much of a midsole. The sole is just very thick and I have yet to really burn the tread on any of Japan Pro's so far (on my third). Overall, highly recommend, plus they look great.
The Vickka Pro also skates great, but less wide foot friendly (no issues personally but a little more snug compared to the Japan Pro). Still skating them right now, but so far I really dig the shoe. Haven't really tested impact protection on these shoes, but just skating my local three and four stair, no issues so far. The flick on this shoe is some of the best I have yet to date from any skate shoe. Overall, just a great shoe.
I prefer the Japan pro for aesthetic reasons mainly, but I'd definitely recommend the Vickka Pro more if you want just a great performing shoe that doesn't have a super thick sole.