I have watched it probably 30 times. A lot about the video is personal preference and I can see how some would say they didn't care for the music.
Personally I like that kind of stuff and I think it caters to a certain type of skater and maybe that person falls into a lot of slap stereotypes.
Strictly skating you can't really fuck with Silas,steve durante,stefan and raymond. The talent and sheer technical tricks they do are some impressive stuff.
The video is a great mix of weird spots,creative editing and making you feel a certain vibe than assaulting you with a barrage of trick after trick.
I always want to go skate after watching it, every time.
The only part I don't watch is Kerry Getz, it's a great part but I just don't care for the guy. I'm not trying to change anyones mind, like what you wanna, I'd rather not critique things to death and put it up against another video. Theyre 2 seperate things, mosaic and photosynthesis are both amazing videos but I'm not gonna try and compare them. I'll just enjoy it for what it is.