Thoughts on the brooks b17? I need a new saddle and I’ve had brooks, but the rubber c17 with the cutout. I really liked them for comfort but they ruined my pants since I’m not riding in Lycra. I’m not worried about it last 100 years or it being waterproof, I’m just worried about my dick falling asleep.
I’m coming from a $60 selle italia novus.
Also looking at these Ergon saddles.
Any input is appreciated. I know they’re basically the goat saddle but I’d like to hear some differing opinions.
If you're willing to break it in properly and treat the leather regularly, then they're supposed to be great. For me, just wasn't worth the time and investment. However, the caveat is I never broke one in from brand new, I only rode other peoples saddles/used ones, so in theory it was molded to someone else's pelvis. Leather can also transfer dye sometimes which will also destroy your pants (or make it look like you shit yourself).
If you are committed to leather, I had a Selle Anatomica that I absolutely loved and didn't require any break in for me, but that was just my experience. YMMV.
As with all saddles, everything is so personal but that's been my experience. I currently have a Brooks Cambium C17 on a commuter that I love.