Heath and Berra together- birdhouse, foundation, birdhouse, then Berra followed him to Alien, but not into retirement (bummer)
Danny Way was on Alien both times he won soty, and went Plan B, alien, plan B- McKay and Duffy also went back after the return- if that counts.
also, Ellington was zero,baker, zero, baker, though really I think he just went back to Zero that one time because he thought baker was failing, and came back when he realized it wasn't.
TK- Baker, element, Baker.