Jeez. Yeah, that just looks like a really defective shoe. Granted, I haven't skated those or any other Fallens, but that just looks inexcusable. Like, there's no way that would get put up for sale.
For me-worst shoes were the Adidas Stan Smith skates right when Adidas started getting back into skating. Not even sure why I got them. There was no board feel and they just felt super lumpy and heavy. I had a pair of Lakai Jerichos that I've complained about before which had a sole that fell apart very quickly, but except for that, I actually really liked how they skated. Other than that, I don't think I've been too disappointed with any of my shoes. At least none that I can remember.