Thanks for recommendations, humans!
Also agree with Spoon, TVotR, Mogwai
Also want to add:
The Notwist, Close to the Glass
tUnE-yArDs, Nikki Nack
Avey Tare's Slasher Flicks, Enter the Slasher House
If I had money, or a lack of guilt, or a less-obsessive mind, my list would be a lot larger