I gave HUF a serious shot and tried several out of the line: Dylan, Pepper, Sutter, and Galaxy.
The Pepper actually felt sloppy on my foot, and the sole felt like it was 6 inches thick. No shape to the shoe, no heel lock and I had to really crank down on the laces to get them secure. I ended up just giving away the Peppers and Sutters.
That's funny, I loved the Peppers. They skated great and lasted a SUPER long time compared to other shoes I've had recently. The Sutters I really liked too. Very low-profile, suede, and had a great flick. Sure, the shoes may not be the most unique things on the planet, but these days nothing is.
Not trying to discount your experience, just giving my two cents.