So after going to rollersnakes and trying on virtually every model of State shoe they had in store, I bought the Madisons. They definitely are a generous size 10.5. They felt perfect in store, but have now softened up to the point where they might be a bit loosey goosey to skate, so probably just keep them as chillers. They seem like the offsping of CONS Lopez and Vans Era Pro, but with a much nicer insole than either. In hindsight I think a size 10 might have been better for skating, as they would probably stretch out to the right size. I found the Keys and Albany too narrow for my foot, and just didn't get on with the Salems, which I really wanted to like because the TKF collab looks so good with the contrasting ollie patch. Other than that all shoes apart from the Madison were true to size. In the Madisons, I would suggest half a size down. Hope that's some useful insight.