So I ended up getting one of the Scumco boards pressed at Control. These are my impressions versus the ones pressed at Pennswood. First the decks seem to feel slightly lighter. I went with the medium concave and I would say it feels similar to a Primitive deck in both concave and kick angle. The nose of the deck appears to be slightly more blunt but that could be from moving up to an 8.5 from an 8. The pop on this board is decent and time will tell if that holds over the life of the deck. I do not feel like this deck has the same extreme pop that you get with a Pennswood deck. It doesn't feel soggy but the deck has quite a bit more flex than the Pennswood one, which has a good bit of age on it. It is a nice deck and I love the company but I may find another company that uses Pennswood for my next deck if Scumco decides to stay with Control. Or find a deck from South Central as they feel similar to Pennswood.
Sounds like you went through the phase I initially did where I figured "oh they wouldn't put out a deck on shit wood... they're ScumCo... it must be me" and tried to convince myself that the pop wasn't that bad or I just got a bad one. Then SneakySecrets got one and had the same experience. Then I got two more and they were the same.
I've heard from a couple people that Pennswood takes forever to fulfill orders (you can't rush quality I guess) so I'm wondering if it wasn't a case of them not being able to get an order done fast enough for ScumCo to do a summer release, especially given that ScumCo has gotten more popular and I'm sure the orders are bigger now than they used to be. Even if that's the case though, I'd much rather they use SC or Chapman or one of the Cali places, or if you're going to go out of the US go for Generator. In the meantime, if you or anyone else wants a Pennswood deck shoot me a PM and I'll try to point you in the right direction. They're sometimes hard to find because they mostly do small brands, but they're out there.
I think the best thing to do is to email ScumCo and let them know the wood is just bad, actually its not even just bad - it's old crail bad. I've got a beat up old chinese creature price point that isn't as dead as these were straight out of the plastic. I've got his address so maybe I'll put dogshit on one and light it on fire and ring his doorbell.
Also, Terror of Planet X new decks aren't on Pennswood anymore, they're Quincy now.