I wonder how many people are actually willing to pay more for goods and services to make sure an American makes decent money. I question this for a few reasons:
1. Macro: Dollar General, Walmart, and Amazon are all known to treat their low level laborers like shit. Does this stop anyone from shopping there? Not many. All three continue to do very well among consumers. Dollar General and Walmart being conservative favorites.
2. Social Science: People are poor predictors of their own behavior. Asking people "What would you do in x scenario?" is awful research, the better questions is, "What did you do in x scenario?" We would all say that we wouldn't shock someone to death because they answered a question wrong, but Milgram showed us that most of us would.
3. Poor Sampling: Much of SLAP isn't always a fan of paying more to support skateboarding, something we've all based our lives around:
https://www.slapmagazine.com/index.php?topic=130377.0 and has already complained about the cost of boards
https://www.slapmagazine.com/index.php?topic=126940.04. Anecdotal: I've tried convincing family members who complain about their working conditions or those lucky enough to have a union job to support companies that are unionized or treat their workers well, none of them give a shit. I repeat what my poli sci prof taught me,"We have two votes in America, our actual vote and our money. " and then add on, "If you want better working conditions shop at places that treat workers well and ignore the places that don't" and they shrug it off. Low prices is all that matters to them.
While I think there is a better moral story around this potential Trumpflation than around the post-pandemic inflation, "We're suffering for other Americans and to make our country strong" vs "restarting factories and supply chains takes time AND lots of people are trying to post-pandemic spend all at the same time", I don't think many will actually give a shit about others. I don't think we are moving into a post-individualist America that embraces communal values. It is like the people who say "spending money on Ukraine is wrong that money could got to help Americans" and then say, "Fuck government housing, fuck socialized medicine, fuck all that communist Marxist shit." They don't want to help Americans, they just want an excuse to not fight against a country that they don't understand. And I certainly don't think Canadians, Europeans, Africans, etc. give a fuck about American jobs nor do I think "Made in America" symbolizes quality like it did 70 years ago.
I can't stress
potential Trumpflation enough as tariff exceptions will be made, companies had to be preparing for this, and companies might quietly eat the costs temporarily to get big tax breaks and get weaker worker safety laws.