Top 5 Best:
Emerica AR Slim - I never get heel bruises in these, they don't blow out in the sole like the Reynolds 3's and they fit better than any other shoe
Vans Half Cab - What can I say, it looks good, feels great, and super skateable
Nike SB Verona Slip On - the most skateable slip-on. period.
Lakai Manchester (OG version with the stitched sole) - lasted me long than any other shoe I ever owned
Emerica Kirchart SDK - amazing sole, board feel, and the perfect amount of padding
Top 5 Worst:
Nike SB Angus - The worst concept ever for a skate shoe
C1RCA Easy Ryder - Sole was too thin
Vans Greco 2 - Way too bulky
Lakai MJ-2 Select - Don't fit right
DC Pure - Ripped within 3 days