I hate these arguments. Everyone involved always ends up looking gayer than they actually are. So, I guess it's my turn. A few thoughts:
-COTG is a legitimately good skater.
-Forget the term "raw," and replace it with the word "relatable." As I thought was explained in the video, all anyone means is that the kind of spots and skating Ricky did in the 90s video parts simply more accurately reflected what a lot of people encountered on the east coast and elsewhere than a lot of pro parts did previously. As he said, he wasn't as good as Mike Carroll or Danny Way, but the kind of skating and editing that was in a lot of videos wasn't as true to what a lot of people did at the time. Sunny weather and perfect schoolyards looks like a lot of fun, but if we can't relate to it, it's like watching a great foreign movie without subtitles. It doesn't mean that P-Rod's skating isn't "raw" or that east coast skating is RAWER. It just means that for a lot of people, the experience captured by Ricky's parts was a lot closer to how they skated. From my own experience, when I was younger my mom would just drop me off downtown and the funnest thing in the world was just going fast and ollieing up curbs and skating whatever we encountered. The ground was often horrible and the spots basically unskatable. So we made what we could of it. So, like if you look at Ricky's opening lines in EE3, that sort of feeling is closer to what I(and a lot of others could relate to) than what parts had been prior to that. I assume these are common feelings for a lot of people who watched those Eastern Exposure videos, and it's why so many people got into Ricky and others from that scene.
-Ricky was a legitimately good skater, and the skills displayed in his parts are something COTG just doesn't seem to be able to grasp. Okay-you can ollie "8 skateboards" can you ollie something that high off of ground that's 200 years old with tons of asshole people in the way? Skateboarding skills are more than just what technical moves you can pull off. It is a skill to be able to skate on rough spots.
-If you watch a lot of parts today, many try to emulate these sorts of things. Like the berrics recent "Off The Grid" parts. I think we can all agree those look so fun and they're *gasp* LA spots, and west coast skaters, like Eric Koston! It's just fun to watch fool. Does that mean that it's more "raw" than his regular video parts? No. It just means it's more relatable.
-I think even COTG would have to admit, if he had the choice of watching 2 video parts, and all he knew about them was that one was filmed in real street spots, and the other was filmed at a skatepark, he would choose the one filmed at street spots. We all would. It just looks cooler and that's undeniable. Suck it bitch.