I've found all the anti-ebike arguments are based in insecurity. Fragile cyclist shit. It's been interesting to watch the rhetoric change as their popularity has grown...whenever their claims are shown to be untrue, they just pick a new one. Where I ride the anti's have just reached the point where they're completely ignored--the thing they fear the most! They tried safety, trail wear, paternalistic "noobs will be hurt / lost", cheating, whatever...it's all bullshit! Every single one of their reasons has been defeated by exposure, and now their heroes (be they famous pros or local legends) are on ebikes, and they're just grumblers...I've been there, into outdated shit and mad that nobody cares and holy shit stop stop stop nobody's listening and the world's passing me by haha it's pretty funny.
It's analogous to bowl troll rules-of-skateboarding guys getting mad at TJ's durag. "This isn't what it's all about!" Turns out the ebikers I know are way more into riding than the purist pedalers. Backwards fundamentalists... (I get to be double SOTY in this analogy, which is sick)
It's hard to unbake the COVID out of the mix. MTB trails went apeshit with all sorts of people who weren't riding before--either short or long-term. And that's still the case. Turns out trail damage per tire isn't any different than a pedal bike, but it was one of the measurable arguments that I was willing to listen to...ebike/rider are 20 pounds more than pedalbike/rider, so there logically could be something there, but I ride with dudes who are 20 pounds lighter / heavier than I am, so it's impossible...ebikes don't roost, that's the main point...and again, lost in sheer numbers of total riders...and yeah if I'm getting four laps instead of my usual two, and that's "twice the damage," would they be stopping someone from getting more hyped on riding and just going more often on their pedal bike? Impossible. Institute a weight limit? No. More riders has definitely turned into more volunteers on the trails for maintenance anyways, which is definitely a plus.
Lots of fast riders are macho pricks, so the idea that someone roasts them on a climb makes them angry. That's it. That's all.
I will return to tell you how rad the last four years of riding eMTB have been but holy shit i'm so hyped