Let's pour one out for our homie SkaterUK1 who was able to go off like a crazy man about Satanist Thrasher causing kids to be gay, but was only banned after he decided to go into the thread for queer skaters and harass them. :'(
It is so unfair that he wasn't able to go into a thread specifically for a group of people who have been treated like shit for decades in skateboarding (so many of us used homophobic slurs and they were everywhere in skate culture in the 90s and 00s), were blocked from being pro (Birdhouse), were killed by mega-ramp skaters, and are persecuted and even executed in other countries. :'( Why is SLAP so unfair to our free-speech advocates?
I haven't seen many banned for promoting crazy ass ideas in any sort of non-hateful way. There have been plenty of conspiracies allowed to thrive on SLAP (the UFO thread). Sneaky went off into a paranoid world, but was often met with comments of respect and polite disagreement. There have been disagreements about all sorts of shit, but it is only when people cross the line into harassment that I've seen them banned. In the case of one extreme kook--who is likely the kookiest person ever to create 50 accounts to avoid his bans--he was allowed to go completely off the rails for far too long.
I'm obviously not a mod--and I'd never want the responsibility--but for me, when it comes to an online forum, there are some lines that can't be crossed. The idea that we want the board to filled with bots, trolls, or neo-nazi kooks is unreasonable. Skateboarding is for the weirdos and the people who didn't fit in at the bro-ass frat/sorority businessman football parties. Making sure SLAP isn't another space that is an uncomfortable place for all the people who--like us--aren't part of this bro-ass world is important. The world has changed, but let's not pretend that the frat boy mentality isn't still dominant, it is just that people outside this world finally have some institutional protection.
That being said, I'll give you that the sexiest woman skater thread hadn't crossed, what I view to be--the line, yet, but no one was banned here.