How does the arch support feel on those 440s? I'm really wanting to try them but my feet are pretty awful these days. I like all the shoes you're comparing them too though so it sounds promising. Currently skating the Lucas premieres myself.
It's decent. Nothing exceptional, but better than the generic Vans Ultracush insole in the Crockett's. Also, the new sole on the 440 is probably the best sole of any skate shoe I've ever had. Grip is amazing and does not show almost any signs of wear after a month of decent skating. NB should put this sole on every shoe they make from here on out. Hoping they do on the 420.
The old NB# Logan 637 was far and away my favorite in the NB# line, and I've literally skated every single shoe NB# has offered since Day 1. This new 440 reminds me quite a bit of the 637 in the way it fits and skates, but better, and I think will appeal to a wider group.
If you're into slim cupsoles, this is your shoe. Only thing that's come close for me recently are the city cups, which also skate great, but are a little block-y and bulkier feeling.