Update after one day of wearing the Carrol's.
Had to swap out the relatively nice Lakai insole for a thin, but wider one I had because they shoes are so tight that I needed more room, even though I went a half size up. The wider insole was because I'm flat footed, so my foot was overhanging the midsole a lot where a normal person's arch is, and it was super uncomfortable after not long.
They actually feel like they'd be good to skate in. Kind of a perfect thickness cupsole.