Crob is in a tough spot. We as skateboarders are trained to look for imperfections, and are part of a sport that generally calls out bullshit. So when someone acts like they're Howard Stern, but they don't have the goods to back that up, there's going to be shit talk. And because Crob isn't willing to start doing research, ask follow up questions, etc. so he could be on Stern's level, he's going to continue to get shit. So he can say it's all trolls or hate, but deep down part of him knows that it's true, which is why I would wager he reacted so negatively upon even hearing about slap. Who wants to be constantly reminded of that thing that you know you should do, but don't want to?
I agree with everything you said except that C-Rob is in a tough spot. He's facing the same predicament everyone faces at one point or another in their careers: do I keep clocking in to do the bare minimum every day without taking advantage of the tools and opportunities at my disposal, or do I use my experience to hone and perfect what I'm doing and use criticism as a chance to excel? He's obviously chosen the former, and like pretty much everyone else who's chosen to milk it in their respective industries (especially skating), he's getting some well-deserved grief for it.
It also doesn't help that these dudes look at this as a technical endeavor, rather than a journalistic endeavor. I hear all the time about "production value" and how many cameras they use and all the time it takes to edit, but how many people here actually watch the show? Whenever I dive in, I know it's gonna be on my phone, and they could use all that editing time to, I don't know, maybe watch a few of their next guest's video parts, read an interview or something? It would take like, an hour of their time, and make the show much better.
So, in short: C-Rob, time to choose if you want to sink or swim. Bagley, you clearly know a lot, but working for Adio in the mid-2000s and taking some sequences of Joey Brezinski doesn't make you a gatekeeper for the culture. I actually don't have any beef with Kelly, and I haven't watched any of the experience episodes, so (thankfully) I don't have opinions on anyone else yet.