440 - Grabbed these next. Super bummed these didn't work out because these seems to always get great colorways. They're more squared off so my middle toes are a little more snug than I'd like, but that might work for your foot shape. The killer for me was the built in arch support. It's high. I'm used to minimalist shoes so after even a half hour in these my soles feel like they lost a fight.
Tried a bunch of shit on today, including the Nygel2.0, it it surprisingly OK, lame colorway imo (RWB).
So, I tried the 306s, same result as before, then decided to try on the 440...10 too big, 9.5...we have a winner!
Wide enough to start and not feel pinchy, they'll surely bag out a bit and just right for toe length; to me, the shape is a hybrid between the 255 round/width and the tips are bit more squared off, like tiago (not like the westgates).

