Expand Quote
I think a lot of things contribute to the difference in shape from the OG Koston 1 to this new 197… one of them is that most likely they are using a different last for this re-issue. Since they are using the tooling (outsole + midsole) of the Quattro they need to stick to the same last used on that shoe (so the upper fits the midsole) and that can change quite a lot the general shape. Also the wider collar shape might be due to the foam used of the original being softer… I’ve noticed that vintage shoes use softer foams than current footwear. A stiffer foam in such a puffy collar will push the collar open, making the top of the eyestay wider and you get that “V” shape down the laces, compared to a more parallel “| |”shape from the OG. I think that’s what made the 197 have that “cone” shape.
With all those things considered, and my fair share of experience in this topic I think they did a decent job. It would never be perfect from the get go.
But I really wish they went the extra length and made it with the OG tooling… so close yet so far. 
Guy that posted the photo confirmed that the shoe is puffier than the og with a thinner tounge.
Doing a decent job on the most requested reissue is bad tbh. Imagine nike releasing the first reissue of the jordan 1 and swapping the sole for something that vaguely looks like it with handball shoe ridges and changing the overall shape...
As bad as the new axion is, their Mariano reissue is on point so it's definitely doable.
That’s what I said… I’m a purist, and pains me to see an half assed job. It looks alright, but since someone made the call to not open the OG tooling the thing was doomed from the get go. The person that had to recreate the upper did a decent job tho (apart from a few details here and there that my eagle eye see).
I think éS probably thought using a “similar” tooling would do the job (plus saving some bucks) and no one would care… but in this case it was a huge miss this being one of the most iconic shoes in their catalogue. Idk what they were thinking.
But I’m also not surprised. I have my fair share of experience at a corporate environment so I know how many dumb opinions and decisions get thrown at you that you have no say on, it can be really frustrating…
Also IMO, the new Axion Genesis is far from a perfect reissue. It’s a good shape and fits more the current day standards (sleeker, longer toe) but the OG was much bulkier/stubbier and they didn’t even make the toebox in rubber. So imho it’s not a 1:1 remake, but looks good, and it’s maybe more relevant as a modern skate shoe.
DC in my opinion is the best at the moment in the reissue game.